You are not alone. Come share the journey.

Sunday, November 15th, 2026: People of the Way, On the Way

20th Anniversary of Parkminster becoming an Affirming Church with guest preachers Revs. Elizabeth and Peter Moffat.

Sermon transcript:

PRM: Greetings Everyone, here and online. Thank you, Joe and the Inclusive Committee, who have asked Elizabeth and me to step out from our treasured place in the back pew to share our reflections on the history and faith of a significant Sunday we experienced with many of you, 20 years ago.

Liz and Bob Forde’s daughter, Laura, was there on November 12th, 2006, and has joined us this morning in honour of what took place that day, which was so affirming for her. Laura has offered us a quote to begin our words today, a quote from the mother of a gay son, who took his own life after suffering from his mother’s judgmental brand of Christian religious intolerance. In her grieving response to the heavy tragedy of losing her son, she became reknown among many as an American LGBTQ Rights activist. Let us heed the wisdom of Mary Griffith and her words:

“Before you echo ‘Amen’ in your home or place of worship, think and remember: a child is listening.”

Thank you, Laura.

EEM: Some of you may remember the remarkable event of the 1988 General Council meeting of the United Church of Canada, held in Victoria, BC. It was at this meeting that clergy and lay commissioners from across the country voted to open the door of leadership in ministry to the LGBTQ Community.

The key clause on which they voted was stated in this manner: “All persons, regardless of their sexual orientation, who profess faith in Christ and obedience to him, are welcome to be or become members of the United Church of Canada. And all members of the United Church are eligible to be considered for the order of ministry.“

Those words were offered in a report by the Division of Ministry, Personnel and Education of our national church and were carefully crafted by the then General Secretary of that Division, the Rev. Richard Moffat. Yes, Richard is Peter’s brother, and, yes, he is here today from his home in Barrie, along with Marion, our sister-in-law, to remember and celebrate this anniversary along with the rest of us.

PRM: It was a brave decision by those commissioners, as the first denomination to make a declaration of this kind, and it subjected us, as a national church, to a lot of media attention.

In the months that followed, fiery debate broke out in congregations across the land, between those who were celebrating the church’s decision, and those who felt betrayed by it. We lost members, yes, in many congregations, yet deep respect drew new members to us. And the denominations to which former members fled eventually had to face the challenge of these very same issues. The United Church of Canada was the denomination that led the way.

EEM: Peter and I will never forget the witness of our own Parkminster member, Marion Mutton, Bruce’s mom, who was a commissioner to that council in Victoria. She was transformed, as many were, by the Spirit at work during those intense days of storytelling, study, and debate.

Then, at the public meetings that were later hosted here, in what was once called Waterloo Presbytery, it was Marion who stood before vitriolic outbursts of anger and responded to these objections with a mother’s understanding, yet imploring, voice. As a result, she was able to challenge minds to reconsider and hearts to be more open. I remember watching her bravely standing her ground, and feeling so deeply proud of her. She became one of my heroes.

PRM: So, in the years that followed, communities were slowly beginning to engage in the process outlined by the national church for becoming “Affirming Congregations.” At the time, there was a strong sense among us here that our congregation was ready to take up the cause. We knew ourselves to be an open, welcoming and progressive faith community, and ready to join the two other churches in our Presbytery that had already become affirming congregations. Indeed, so sure were we of a positive outcome, that we set a goal for our vote to have to pass by a two-thirds majority.

EEM: Parkminster then established a steering committee to lead us through the process and to provide study opportunities and private, confidential sessions, to help members deal with their questions and concerns.

Though the membership of this steering group was made up of people across a spectrum of opinion, it must be said, that in their research and explorations together over a year’s time, all its members became enthusiastic for the cause. And you know what they say about converts!

It is possible that those who had not yet taken the leap of faith on this issue were feeling somewhat judged by this outspoken group.

So the day of the vote came, with members and adherents packing all these pews both down here in the nave and up there in the gallery. And believe me, emotions ran high. Peter preached that morning and his text was the same one we have chosen for today.

PRM: The simple story of the widow’s tiny, but sacrificial, offering implies that what is being asked of us as faithful followers is nothing less than a total offering of our lives, when it comes to promoting God’s Kin-dom.

No doubt, we all remember the farmyard tale of the dialogue between the hen and the pig, about which of the two animals gives the most for the farmer’s breakfast of eggs and bacon. “It’s easy for you to talk,” the pig says to the hen. “All you do is make a token contribution, while I give nothing less than my life.”

Though this text is generally used in a stewardship sermon that challenges our financial givings at the end of the year, both the witness of the pig and of the widow go further in challenging how deeply we, as People of the Way, are prepared to follow Jesus, knowing he is heading for a political confrontation that ended on a Cross.

EEM: Was our openness to becoming an Affirming Congregation understood by members to be an egg offering of acceptance, like an invitation for the LGBTQ community to come through our doors to worship and share our coffee hour? Did our decision come just from our well known friendliness and outreach as the Parkminster congregation? Or was the decision asking something more sacrificial from us, something more on the order of the pig and the generous widow, something that required us to stand up in solidarity with gay members in the fight for their freedoms and rights?

Was the decision asking us something that might require a risk to our personal security and our reputation as a congregation? Would we be igniting the ire of more evangelical communities, who were continuing to deny God’s gift of authenticity and blessing to the gay community? And how would we handle that kind of challenge and controversy?

PRM: The seriousness of this difference in our understanding has to do with our identity as being both People of the Way, and being People on the Way with Jesus: people who not only include others, but people who become One with others as Allies in the active march toward justice — people who demonstrate that the Kin-dom of God’s Love is compelling us onward.

The biblical witness is full of examples of what God’s Kin-dom is like. Centuries ago, the prophet Isaiah captured its risky essence by suggesting that it would be a place where lambs and wolves might actually live together without fear (Isaiah 11).

Micah described its life-giving reality in terms of swords being beaten and transformed by fire into ploughshares of peace (Micah 4:3).

Years later, Mary anticipated the reconciling power of her Son, as one who would inaugurate a time of healing for those who were broken by prejudice and discrimination (Luke 1:50), a time when those who were spiritually and physically hungry would be filled with good things; a time when the proud, with all their entitlements and plans would be scattered.

EEM: When the ballots were finally counted that auspicious Sunday, the two-thirds majority required to pass was achieved by just two votes. It was so close that we were all a bit shell shocked, gut punched in a way
that we couldn’t bring ourselves to celebrate or even clap. The air in our corporate lungs had been knocked out of us as we came to realize that we were not quite the cohesive people we thought we were, and that our positions on this issue ranged along a wide scale between acceptance, solidarity, and fear.

Remember these? (show masks) They were the wedding favours from our first public gay marriage conducted in this sanctuary for our own Allen Switzer and his then partner, Jim — two grooms who invited the entire congregation to come to their wedding ceremony and to the Mardi Gras reception that followed.

It was only at that event, months after becoming an Affirming Congregation, that I felt we began, as members, to fully claim our decision as something right and good.

It was the confirmation of our decision that came as a spiritual gift with that marriage, that allowed us at last to celebrate amidst the rollicking atmosphere of a very fun evening, laughing and dancing together with each other in all kinds of configurations. Thank you, Allen.

PRM: But the more sacrificial price of the Affirming Decision was yet to come in October of 2017, with the flying of the Pride flag at our Erb Street curb and the announcement on our street sign of a community potluck dinner for LGBTQ guests and allies.

Graffitti appeared overnight outside the church from a protestor with a Biblical judgement coming from the Book of Romans 1:28, about the Church needing to remain ‘Holy’. It was quite a challenge to have to defend the congregation, for Joe and Heather, who had only recently come to Parkminster as the new clergy team.

Yet, the two of them demonstrated just how aligned with the Gospel this ‘Holy’ and ‘Affirming’ congregation truly was, as they confronted questions from an inquiring media both in print and on the radio.

EEM: I can personally identify with the feelings of trepidation those two no doubt felt, having to defend a gospel stance before the naysayers with their righteous justifications. Because one Saturday afternoon, when I was here with a group of TCOW teenagers on retreat, a very tall and imposing man, accompanied by a bible clutching woman, came into the narthex at the back of the sanctuary, asking to speak to the minister.

After explaining to them that our ministers would be back the next day on Sunday and that they were welcome to come back or leave a note, I was asked to explain what the flag on our curb meant. Immediately, I could feel a cloud of confrontation rising up between us, as I nervously tried to describe the flag as a signal to everyone that our church was a safe sanctuary for all communities. It was then that this earnest pair, no doubt believing themselves to be true Christian soldiers of God’s Truth, unleashed a stern biblical rebuke, heading for a debate that was not going to end gracefully.

Stopping them cold, I asked if they would please leave, because that flag they were so concerned about promised protection from the very kind of views they were expressing. Thankfully for me, both of them turned on their heels and left, even as I could feel my bones melting on the spot.

PRM: Being Christ Followers, both of and on the Way, means so much more than a mere egg offering. For joining with Jesus means we will find ourselves having to face our fears, as he had to face his, and having to make the kind of sacrificial commitments and acts that the widow in our biblical story made with a coin that embodied the totality of her resources. Yet it is in the times when we act bravely that we are surprised by Easter ironies of the Spirit that we never could have anticipated.

Members of the Inclusive Committee described to us some of the amazing repercussions of that graffiti incident of long ago. Once the story was out in the news, fifty KW citizens, in solidarity with us, showed up for the advertised potluck supper. And the local police, out of their own concern for our safety, provided the protection of a squad car, parked at our door, decked out in the Pride rainbow colours, and with the letters “LGBTQ” displayed on each side of their vehicle.

EEM: There are churches that think by voting to become Affirming Congregations, they have reached the last step in a long process that allows them to place the picture of a rainbow outside on their church sign. Yet what Peter and I so appreciate about Parkminster is the recognition that to be an affirming congregation is not an end in itself. Instead, it puts us on the road of discovery with a Jesus who is constantly moving out into the world to discern and address the needs of each generation. This discernment is the kind of leadership that our Inclusive Committee seeks to practice as they open us to places where God might be calling us to extend our inclusiveness and solidarity with others.

To be an Affirming Church is the ongoing process of becoming People not just of the Way, but Pilgrims on the Way — people who, before we say “Amen”, stop to remember that “a child is listening”.

In conclusion, we want to share words from three prophets of our current era:

The first comes from someone we know as our minister. In a sermon he offered back in September of this year he said this: “Faith is a relationship in which we surrender our agendas, pay attention, and listen deeply to where love might be calling and leading us.” Thank you, Joe.

The second is a quote from what the Chair of our Board said to the press at the time of the graffiti incident:
“Jesus opened his heart and his hands and his mind to all humanity, and that’s what we do.” Thank you, Maedith Radlein.

PRM: The third prophetic quote comes from someone whom Elizabeth and I have come to value during the build up to the Midterm elections in the States, and who is now the Democratic Senator-Elect from the State of Texas, James Talarico:

“My faith teaches me,” he says, “that love is the strongest force in the Universe. Love is not passive, neutral, nor weak. Love requires that we stand between the bullies and the bullied. Love requires that we look evil in the eye and not blink. Love can heal what’s broken in America…” and among us.

And so, on this day when we celebrate 20 years as an Affirming Church, and have officially apologized to the 2SLGBTQIA+ community for our failure to see or appreciate the Holy Diversity of those within God’s loving embrace, may we renew our brave commitment of Faith with Jesus, to be both People of and on the Way.

Blessed be. Amen.